2009 BMW M5 Market Value & Price History
The 2009 BMW M5 has a market value of $32,598, based on 10 verified auction sales tracked by DriveIndex, with half of the verified USD sales since 2021 between $17,000 and $45,000. No sale since Dec 2, 2025, so this value may not reflect today's market. 3 have sold in the past 12 months, and 3 are listed for sale from $28,000 to $112,000. The median sale price is down 37.6% over the past 12 months versus one to three years ago.
Data: DriveIndex. 10 verified auction sales for the 2009 BMW M5, latest sale Dec 2, 2025. Methodology
What members see for the 2009 BMW M5
The value above is the headline. Members get the full picture behind it.
- All 10 sold prices, and where each one sold
- The live Value Signal, and how confident it is
- A 1–5 year value projection
- A Buy / Hold / Sell call
- An alert the moment one lists or sells
- The best and worst months to buy and sell
- An estimated market-bottom date
- Whether each of the 3 asks listed for sale is fair
- Deal Radar: underpriced listings across the market
Not ready? A free account shows the current value and recent sale dates.
Unlock the DriveIndex Value Signal to see whether this car is appreciating, stable, or depreciating, its projected value over the next 1–5 years, and the best months to buy and sell.
Open the M5 on DriveIndex →2009 BMW M5 For Sale (3)
Last checked Oct 6, 2026, unless a listing shows its own date
Recent 2009 BMW M5 Auction Results
| Sold | Price | Mileage | Gearbox |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 2, 2025 | $45,250 | 72,000 mi | Manual |
| Dec 1, 2025 | $15,610 | 154,000 mi | — |
| Oct 16, 2025 | $12,750 | 130,000 mi | — |
| Sep 11, 2025 | $54,000 | 27,000 mi | Manual |
| Mar 14, 2025 | $25,000 | 94,000 mi | — |
| Mar 2, 2024 | $24,000 | 90,000 mi | — |
| May 5, 2023 | $45,000 | 64,000 mi | Manual |
| Apr 1, 2023 | $33,000 | 41,000 mi | — |
| Aug 24, 2022 | $17,000 | 61,200 mi | Automatic |
| Jan 11, 2021 | $27,500 | 73,000 mi | Manual |
Verified results from the world's leading collector-car auction houses and marketplaces.
All BMW M5 auction results →See the full picture on the 2009 BMW M5
Browsing is free. Upgrade to unlock the Value Signal™, projections, and the tools collectors use to buy and sell at the right time.
- Full Value Signal™ + confidence: appreciating, stable, or depreciating
- 1–5 year price projections
- Buy / Hold / Sell call per car
- Complete sales & listings feed + up to 10 yrs of history
- Analyst notes & compare up to 4 cars
- Price & custom alerts (make, color, options)
- Portfolio tracker (garage) + analytics
- Everything in Pro, plus:
- Portfolio Outlook (a hold/sell call for every car you own)
- Watchlist Intelligence (act-now calls on the cars you follow)
- Head-to-Head Verdict (compare cars, the data crowns the buy)
- Market Deal Radar (every live ask under market value, catalog-wide)
- Best & worst months to buy and sell
- What each option adds to the price + separate manual vs automatic values
- Listing analyzer with fair-value deal scores
- Rad’s Market Update (his picks & price targets)
BMW M5 by Year
Which M5 year should you buy? Every year compared →2009 BMW M5: Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a 2009 BMW M5 worth?
A 2009 BMW M5 is worth approximately $32,598, based on 10 verified auction sales tracked by DriveIndex. No sale since Dec 2, 2025, so this value may not reflect today's market. Half of all verified sales fall between $17,000 and $45,000; the full verified range is $12,750 to $54,000. Condition, mileage and options move an individual car within that band.
How much did a 2009 BMW M5 cost new?
The 2009 BMW M5 carried an original MSRP of $82,900. Its DriveIndex market value is $32,598. No sale since Dec 2, 2025, so this value may not reflect today's market.
How much has the 2009 BMW M5 depreciated?
The 2009 BMW M5 is worth about 61% less than it cost new: it carried an original MSRP of $82,900, and its DriveIndex market value is $32,598. That compares the DriveIndex value with the sticker price, not adjusted for inflation. No sale since Dec 2, 2025, so this value may not reflect today's market.
How many 2009 BMW M5 sell per year?
3 have sold at auction in the past 12 months. DriveIndex has tracked 10 2009 BMW M5 sales in total.
Are 2009 BMW M5 sale prices higher or lower than a year ago?
The median 2009 BMW M5 sale price is down 37.6% over the past 12 months versus one to three years ago, based on verified auction sales. That figure tracks the median of what actually sold, so it moves with the mix of mileages and options that came to market as well as with the market itself. The full Value Signal classification (appreciating, stable, bottomed, or depreciating) and its 1–5 year projection are part of DriveIndex Pro.
Where can I buy a 2009 BMW M5?
DriveIndex lists 3 2009 BMW M5 for sale, priced from $28,000 to $112,000 (last checked Oct 6, 2026). DriveIndex aggregates for-sale listings and auction results from the world's leading collector-car auction houses and marketplaces.
More BMW Models
All BMW models →Collections Featuring BMW
Pro unlocks its live Value Signal, every sold price, a 1–5 year projection and an alert the moment one lists or sells. Collector adds the best months to buy and sell and where the market bottoms.
Get Pro →