DriveIndex
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

2012 Ferrari 458 Market Values & Price History

DriveIndex tracks 2 versions of the 2012 Ferrari 458, with market values from $333,616 to $450,541, built on 31 verified auction sales (data through Nov 17, 2026). 29 are listed for sale. The value of one depends on the version, so each has its own figure below.

Track 458 values free →All Ferrari models
Value Range
$333,616 – $450,541
Median Sale
$224,580
Sold Price Range
$145,000 – $490,000
Auction Sales
31
Sold, Last 12 Mo
11
For Sale
29
Last checked Nov 17, 2026

Data: DriveIndex. 31 verified auction sales across 2 versions of the 2012 Ferrari 458, latest sale Oct 22, 2026. Methodology

2012 Ferrari 458 Versions & Values (2)

VersionMarket ValueSalesFor Sale
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia$333,6161720
2012 Ferrari 458 Spider$450,541149

Recent 2012 Ferrari 458 Auction Results

SoldVersionPriceMileageGearbox
Oct 22, 2026Spider$450,0005,523 miAutomatic
Oct 20, 2026Italia$249,37527,274 miAutomatic
Oct 12, 2026Italia$440,0002,400 miAutomatic
Sep 24, 2026Italia$341,0009,000 miAutomatic
Sep 10, 2026Italia$338,10016,118 miAutomatic
Aug 25, 2026Spider$490,0004,400 miAutomatic
Jul 14, 2026Spider$310,00033,000 miAutomatic
May 21, 2026Italia$232,98231,025 mi—
Apr 13, 2026Italia$234,00035,000 miAutomatic
Feb 13, 2026Italia$224,58025,000 mi—
Jan 21, 2026Spider$270,00015,000 mi—
Jun 20, 2025Spider$194,00027,000 miAutomatic
Apr 11, 2025Italia$212,7226,000 miAutomatic
Jan 25, 2025Spider$154,000—Automatic
Jan 24, 2025Spider$159,500—Automatic

Verified results from the world's leading collector-car auction houses and marketplaces.

Ferrari 458 by Year

201120122013
Go deeper on the 2012 Ferrari 458

Pro ($19.99/month) unlocks the Value Signal for each version that has one (appreciating, stable, bottomed, approaching bottom or depreciating), its 1–5 year projection and every sold price. Collector ($39.99/month) adds the best months to buy and sell. A free account shows current values and recent sale dates.

Start with a free account →

2012 Ferrari 458: Frequently Asked Questions

How much is a 2012 Ferrari 458 worth?

Market values for the 2012 Ferrari 458 range from $333,616 to $450,541, depending on the version. The median verified sale across all versions is $224,580, from 31 verified auction sales.

Which versions of the 2012 Ferrari 458 does DriveIndex track?

2 versions, including Italia, Spider. Each has its own market value, price history and recent sales on DriveIndex.

How many 2012 Ferrari 458 cars are for sale?

29 are listed for sale across the versions DriveIndex tracks (last checked Nov 17, 2026), with asking prices from $189,900 to $656,521.