Ferrari 458 Italia For Sale
101 Ferrari 458 Italia are listed for sale (including 3 auctions), with asking prices from $185,889 to $1,333,010, averaging 18,366 miles (data through Oct 9, 2026). For context, the 458 Italia's market value runs $230,213 to $486,467 depending on year and condition, built from 102 verified auction sales, not asking prices.
Ferrari 458 Italia Listings (101)
Last checked Oct 9, 2026, unless a listing shows its own date
+ 71 more listings in the DriveIndex app.
Asking prices as listed when last checked, not sold prices. Market values on DriveIndex come from verified completed sales.
Collector ($39.99/month) includes the Listing Analyzer: it scores any 458 Italia ask against its mileage-adjusted fair value from verified sales, with the deal score and the exact dollar gap. Deal Radar lists the asks under fair value across the whole market.
Check the 23 2011 458 Italia listings with Collector →Not ready? A free account shows current values and recent sale dates.
Ferrari 458 Italia For Sale: Frequently Asked Questions
How many Ferrari 458 Italia are for sale?
101 Ferrari 458 Italia listings are listed across the marketplaces DriveIndex tracks (last checked Oct 9, 2026).
How much does a Ferrari 458 Italia cost?
Asking prices range from $185,889 to $1,333,010. The market value from verified completed sales runs $230,213 to $486,467. Asking prices and sold prices are not the same thing.
Is a Ferrari 458 Italia listing priced fairly?
DriveIndex's Listing Analyzer scores any Ferrari 458 Italia listing against its mileage-adjusted fair value from verified sales: the deal score, the exact dollar gap, and where the ask lands. The Listing Analyzer is a DriveIndex Collector feature.
When is the best time to buy a Ferrari 458 Italia?
DriveIndex measures each model's seasonal pattern across years of verified sales and identifies the best months to buy and sell, a DriveIndex Collector feature. Whether the 458 Italia is appreciating, stable, or depreciating is the Value Signal, part of DriveIndex Pro.